by Joël Dicker
translated from the French by Sam Taylor
643 pp. $18.00
May 27, 2014
It may be unfair of me but all the while during the first 100+ pages of Joël Dicker's mammoth The Truth About the Harry Quebert Affair I kept hearing the strains of the Twin Peaks TV theme music. And I pictured the beaming face of Sheryl Lee as Laura Palmer each time Nola Kellergan appears in the many flashback sequences. Both Dicker's novel and the cult TV show of the 90s tell the story of a missing girl, the discovery of her body, and the slow reveal of who killed her. But as the labyrinthine story unfolds the Twin Peaks similarities soon dissipate and give way to something more subtle and subversive and -- dare I say it -- impressive.
Unwittingly Joël Dicker, a young Swiss novelist, has unleashed a Frankenstein's monster with the publication of this book. Part whodunit, part satire of the publishing industry, and part writer's handbook it has essentially become a work of fiction come to life. In Dicker's novel a young writer Marcus Goldman becomes a sensation in the literary world when he publishes a book called The Truth About the Harry Quebert Affair. (Oh yes, this is a also a work of metafiction.) The book is an instant sensation and he becomes the darling of the media. So too has Dicker whose novel first published in Europe has become a mega-hit resulting in interview after interview and travel all over the globe to talk about this unique example of reality mirroring fiction. So much travel, in fact, that he has temporarily made his home in London to make air travel simpler rather than remaining at home in Geneva where direct air flights are at a minimum. Already an international bestseller for the past year Dicker's novel has at last been translated into English and is being simultaneously released in the UK and the US today, May 27.
Not only has Dicker become the flavor of the month in crime fiction, his book (only his sophomore effort no less) has won three European literary awards including the prestigious Grand Prix du Roman from the Academie Française. Has Dicker really written a mini masterpiece, whether it be mainstream or genre fiction? Well, not really. But it is an awful lot of fun trying to figure out both the mystery of the ridiculously complex plot as well as trying to understand the reason for all the hype attached to this new writer's book.
At its core ...Harry Quebert Affair is a literary detective novel. Quebert, a literary sensation himself in the world of the novel, was Goldman's college writing instructor, mentor and eventually a good friend. While visiting Quebert for some inspiration during Goldman's severe writer's block crisis a horrible crime is literally unearthed and Quebert is thrust into the limelight as prime suspect. The body of Nola Kellergan, a teenage girl who went missing back in 1975, is unearthed in a hidden grave located on the grounds of Quebert's New Hampshire retreat. Goldman is determined to clear the name of his beloved friend and writing mentor and for the next 600+ pages (!) we follow his dogged investigation into the past of Somerset, New Hampshire, a typical New England village with more than its fair share of dirty secrets.
|Joël Dicker ©Jeremy Spierer|
I could use this review to write about the tangled plotlines, the shifts in viewpoint, the dizzying twists that keep changing how Nola is perceived or how the relationship between Marcus and Harry undergoes rifts and changes more harmful than good. But that's what all the other reviewers are writing about. What really ought to be marvelled at is what Dicker does with the genre itself. The novel is an consummate example of the ultimate challenge between reader and mystery writer, a sure temptation for readers who loved to devour the old-fashioned puzzlers of the Golden Age. Once upon a time we read mysteries to be baffled, to be fooled and to have a clever storyteller pull the rug out from under us and leave us gasping for breath or laughing in admiration for having been outsmarted. Dicker mixes both hoary old clichés (anonymous messages, secret diaries) with contemporary thriller standbys (grisly crimes, psychosexual abnormalities, a hint of tawdriness) and comes up with a crackerjack tale that both entertains and manipulates the reader.
The world Dicker creates is wholly artificial as in the best of Golden Age detective novels. We are in an entirely fanciful world where writers are superstar celebrities instantly recognizable from their DJ photos. Everyone knows Marcus Goldman, everyone has read his book. Even Harry and his mega bestseller The Origin of Evil (ironically a love story) receives the same hyperbolic attention. This is a wholly mythologized world of the novelist, something that was barely a reality when celebrity authors regularly appeared on 1970s talk shows. Like the world of John Dickson Carr where ancient estates are haunted by ghosts and criminals commit elaborate crimes in baroquely sealed rooms meant to bamboozle and confound the police so too has Dicker created an entirely artificial world where novelists are hero worshiped as demigods and treated with both awe and sycophancy usually reserved for rock stars or professional athletes. It's a wish fulfillment kind of writing to be sure and yet it is done so with the primary purpose of misleading the reader just as the great Golden Age writers did.
However, when Dicker lays off his nausea motif, discards the gimmick of the novel within the novel (which is often ham-handed), and decides to focus on Nola's perplexing and contradictory life and her mysterious death the novel is utterly engaging. His plot pyrotechnics are his strength. They are audacious and preposterous and yet perfectly suited for his ultimate aim. The Truth About the Harry Quebert Affair is one of the best examples of a retro style crime novel whose only goal is to fool the reader with a gasp inducing finale. Joël Dicker succeeds in pulling off one of the best literary deceptions in years and ought to be applauded for the sheer chutzpah of his 600+ page magic trick.
Very interesting review. Makes me want to read it, just to see what it is like, except I don't want to acquire such a long book at this time. Have too many others to read. You do a good job of convincing readers (at least this one) that it is worth a try.ReplyDelete
If you have the patience to put up with its flaws and massive length it can be a lot of fun. Just don't expect a literary masterpiece as some of the European critics are trying to convince us.Delete
I wouldn't know a Twin Peaks theme if it bumped my ankle. Which is about as big a deal as the creative thought which went into the cover design(s) for this book. "Throw some text on the front." "No, wait, through some text on the front in a different font. If there had been an art director (but obviously there was not) that person should be fired.ReplyDelete
As for the book itself, sounds okay.
I don't like either cover myself. The US edition at the top does a better job of using images relative to the story. Seagulls are a heavy handed symbol in the book and the seashore plays a big part in the story. New Hampshire has hardly ANY coastline (12 miles, I think) yet you'd think the entire eastern border was the Atlantic ocean the way Dicker describes all the different beaches. He lived in NH when he was a kid, but I think he's romanticizing and exaggerating his memories of the ocean.Delete
I just noticed that the letters on the US edition are done in the style of those metal numbers and letters made to adhere to mailboxes and front doorways. A very subtle 70s touch there.
Hey, we have 18 miles of coastline up here in New Hampshire....Delete
I like the review, and you had me wanting to read the book until you listed the things that bothered you about it--I'm pretty sure the same things would bug me and I would probably be less tolerant.
I'll take a different book to one of the many fine NH beaches, I think.
Your instincts are right, Rick. This is definitely not for the impatinet or intolerant reader. I've read trenchant US reviews that advise the reader to skip the first 250 pages and start in the second section. Ouch! Like I said...not a masterpiece. Those hardy enough to survive the bumpy road of the first third of this tome get more than they ever bargained for in terms of surprises and shocks when the story really kicks in. A shame it takes too long to get there.Delete
I stand corrected on the length of NH's fine coastline. I lived in North Conway, far away from the Atlantic, one summer back in the mid 80s. All I remember are the mountains...and snow in August!
We live on the other end of 302, four miles from the Vermont border as opposed to Maine's. In eight years I've only seen the NH coastline twice. But the mountains, those are home.ReplyDelete
(And there's a fire-baked pizza place in North Conway that calls us to the eastern side regularly....)
I recently hosted a Twin Peaks party for my sister's bachelorette to-do. Even if it doesn't maintain the Lynchian vibe, this still sounds like it hits a lot of notes I'd be interested in.ReplyDelete