Anne Hocking is another of the many second tier mystery writers who, when she put her mind to it, could concoct a murder tale populated with fascinating characters and perplexing events without a shred of fanciful gadgets, quirky antics from an eccentric detective or any other froth that tends to make a lot of people turn away from detective novels of the early 20th century. Poison is A Bitter Brew is one smart, calculating and thoroughly engrossing story.
All this came as a surprise to me because the plot sounded very run-of-the-mill. At the heart of the story you have your basic "Who killed the heirs?" tale and one in which money seems to be the underlying motive for a series of poisoning deaths. But which death is an accident and which is murder? And could one of them actually be a suicide? This is all left up to Chief Inspector William Austen to discover as he infiltrates the repressed household of Augusta Milverton and her odd group of relatives. There is a restrictive legacy attached to the Milverton estate and Augusta is forced to deal with its misogynistic instructions from her long dead, woman-hating father. The Milverton money can only be passed down through the male lineage as outlined in her father's will and Augusta, one of these familiar "spinster for life" women we encounter in detective fiction, is not happy with the group of nephews who are her immediate relatives nor how they line up in their chronology. Charles Temple, the youngest, least responsible yet the most appealing of the nephews is her favorite. She would like him to be the primary legatee but cannot change her will thanks to the legal entanglements created by her father. She is stuck with the philandering dullard George Hayle, the oldest and first in line to her fortune followed by the asexual and aloof Osbert Garstin. Neither earn much respect or affection from Augusta.
It's all very familiar, isn't it? Hundreds of detective novels have been written revolving around this timeworn plot. But Hocking makes the story immensely readable. The characters are so well drawn from the usual garrulous and devoted servant Tamsin, who knows all and intuits more, to the central character of imperious Augusta Milverton. Even Austen has some traits that raise him out of the middle ground of second rate detectives. Hocking who comes from a literary family also has fun with literary allusions. The characters quote from poetry and literature, there are references to detective fiction with Poirot and Lord Peter Wimsey name-dropped at two key points. One notable highlight: Austen lectures his cohort Sergeant Pendarvis on the merits of reading detective fiction. He says the books remind him of what many policemen tend to forget is key to crime solving -- "the insistence on the importance of the human factor." Hocking believes this wholeheartedly as well. As the story progresses in Poison Is a Bitter Brew Hocking increasingly focusses on the complexity of the "murderer personality" as she has Austen call it. He comes to the astonishing conclusion based on evidence and circumstance that there are most likely two killers in the house, both of whom share a similar psychological make-up. Family devotion takes on a far serious note and characters flittering about in the shadows will advance to center stage in an eyebrow raising denouement that mixes justice with sorrow.
Anne Hocking's books were mostly published in the UK with a only a few titles receiving US editions. Of all her books Poison is A Bitter Brew seems to be the most easily found. It's the first book I've read of hers and according to her bibliography the third of her detective novels featuring Inspector Austen. Though on the surface it may appear to be a tale all too often told in Hocking's capable hands this story of money and love, greed and desire, is carried off with panache and grace.
I've knocked another title off my Golden Age Vintage Mystery Reading Challenge Bingo card. This one fits space O5 - "Method of murder in the title". Trying to get this card filled by October 15. Think I can do it?
I'm reading J.J. Connington's Murder in the Maze which has similar plot elements.ReplyDelete
Like I said it's well worn territory in the detective novel. I probably could come up with a list of at least 100 books with this basic plot, Rick. I especially liked the family dynamics in this one. These characters made for fascinating reading despite the familiar situations. I wrote this too hastily perhaps intent on getting it posted today before 12 noon. Given time and thoughtful consideration I could've drawn parallels to the work of Ross Macdonald, Ruth Rendell and others who have delved into secretive behavior within tightly knit families in their fiction. The underlying motive for the two crimes is unusual and shows keen insight into unnatural devotion and how it can be equated to a desire for personal power and control over another. It's pretty modern in that regard.Delete
Is the obvious resemblance to Sherlock Holmes's "The Adventure of Charles Augustus Milverton" in Augusta Milverton's name significant or another reference to detective fiction?ReplyDelete
Good heavens! I didn't even catch that. And her nephew's name is Charles. What a clever one, that Anne is. But wasn't Milverton a notorious blackmailer? No blackmail going on in this book. Just a lot of experimenting with the potentially toxic properties of rhubarb. Augusta may be as unpleasant and odious as Conan Doyle's villain but she's not a blackmailer. She's an uptight prude in fact, very much a product of her Victorian upbringing.Delete
I reviewed one by her that was a disappointment, but have liked some others by her. She definitely was of the "manners mystery" school, after having done straight novels, then thrillers. Great pic of her, where did you find that?ReplyDelete
It comes from a Spanish translation of an anthology of her novels. It was used as a frontispiece in that book, probably comes from the rear DJ of one of her novels published in the UK. My guess is that the photo dates from the late 50s or early 60s. It was posted on a Spanish bookselling website and then reposted again at the blog Furrowed Middlebrow to illustrate a post there on all the Hocking sisters: Anne, Elizabeth Nisot (who also wrote crime ficition and receives a dedication from Anne in this mystery novel) and Sybil.Delete
Sounds good, John. Good title, too. I do love 'a fortune hangs in the balance' family murders most especially if there's something unexpected about them. One wonders how any heirs ever survived to inherit. Ha.ReplyDelete
This sound sgreat John and, as always, glad to hear that it can actually be found by mere mortals! Thanks chum.ReplyDelete
Haven't heard of Hocking at all, and this sounds very good. Will have to look for a copy. You inspire me to buy too many books and I already have more than I can handle.ReplyDelete