Crime, Supernatural and Adventure fiction. Obscure, Forgotten and Well Worth Reading.
Friday, February 24, 2017
FFB: The D.A.'s Daughter - Herman Petersen
This is a pleasant enough detective novel with an amiable hero and some well drawn characters. But it's also an unusually subversive novel. Hank is probably about 19 years old (he's about to enter his first year of college) and yet he has an oddly intimate friendship with the 30-something Mrs. Andrews. They first meet at the lake that borders Mrs. Andrews' now deceased husband's property. She spends a lot of time sunbathing on the lakefront dock where Hank likes to swim. Her husband used to chase away the kids when Hank was younger. In a flashback he recounts his first meeting with Mrs. Andrews back in his high school days. At this meeting Hank teaches Mrs. Andrews how to swim. It all has a Benjamin/Mrs. Robinson vibe to it though Petersen never makes Mrs. Andrews appear to be the aggressor. Hank does wonder if she has more in mind but he stays a gentleman throughout. The swimming lessons continue for months right up to Mrs. Andrews' death.
Later, there is another scene with an older woman, but this time the attraction is all imagined. Hank has a plan to invite himself to dinner at the home of Clarabelle Thompson, a tough mannish woman who runs a cattle farm. She has him help her with a plowing chore but he slips and falls into mud. She takes him into her house, gets him to undress and bathe while she makes him dinner. Hank interrogates her slyly at dinner about her involvement in Mrs. Andrews death and the farmer starts to get irritated. Keep in mind that Hank is half naked all through dinner wearing an oversize robe his hostess has given him and nothing else. Still, she invites Hank to spend the night while his clothes are being washed and dried, but Hank gets nervous thinking she has an ulterior motive. This causes Clarabelle, a woman old enough to be his Hank's mother, to burst out laughing. "Lock your door," she tells him, "if you think I might be after you." And goes to bed still laughing to herself. You don't often encounter these scenes in 1940s era mystery novels, maybe with adults but not with a 19 year old boy and a 40 year old woman.
More risqué sex farce stuff is to come. Hank strips and goes to bed naked only to be wakened by stones being thrown at the window. He goes to the window with a sheet wrapped around his crotch likening himself to Tarzan in a loincloth. Turns out Lydia is outside wondering why he never made it home. An amusing scene follows as she gets the nearly naked Hank into her car and sneaks him back to his house. All the during the ride home Lydia teases him with jibes and banter about what he was up to with Clarabelle.
This was Petersen's last detective novel of only four books. While it held my interest with its attractive young couple in their twenties and gave yet another look into life in rural upstate New York during the war years The D.A.'s Daughter was not as good as Old Bones previously reviewed on this blog. Fans of subversive detective novels might be interested in the "cougar" scenes and those who like their detectives youthful and impetuous will definitely find a lot to entertain them.
This is my contribution to the "Crimes of the Century" meme for February for which we read books published in 1943. Check out the rest of the books explored at Past Offenses.
Posted by J F Norris at 7:29 AM
Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)
This sounds good, John. As usual, I've never heard of the author but never mind. You describe this as 'amiable and pleasant' and yet 'subversive' - I'm intrigued. :)ReplyDelete
Mrs. Andrews, are you trying to seduce me? Oops, wrong script. As to subversion, I'm all for it!ReplyDelete
sounds very unusual, and tempting - in more ways than one...ReplyDelete
John, you definitely have me interested in this one, and I will have to look for Old Bones also.ReplyDelete
These are good mysteries, Tracy, with OLD BONES the better of the two. I'm interested in Herman Petersen's other two mystery novels and may sneak in one more Petersen review in the spring.Delete
Don't know quite what it says about me, but I really like the sound of this. I was immediately thinking of the much later Kingslay Amis detective novel that really capitalised on the teenage protagonist and his relationship with an older woman. But this got there 30 years earlier - honour is due ...ReplyDelete
I read that book. Riverside Villa Murders, I think is the title. John Irving and Peter DeVries write about that kind of relationship a lot too. But it's a phenomenon that I equate with the 60s and 70s but like any type of attraction it's always been timeless. Wasn't off putting just eyebrow raising.Delete